“How do I deal with my 5-year-old daughter when she doesn’t obey me? This is with everything…. And I have to tell her over and over. Time-out is not working, what are some discipline techniques?” ~ Searching for Answers
God has given us as parents the responsibility to govern (direct, restrain, regulate, and control) our children as we teach them to govern themselves. When they don’t obey our loving direction and instruction, they are not governing themselves. An appropriate consequence is that they must remain where you can govern them, because they aren’t governing themselves. In other words, she needs to stay in your presence until she begins to govern herself by obeying. If you need to go to the laundry room, she needs to come too. If you need to do some work at your desk or table, she needs to sit there too. If you need to change some diapers, she needs to come too. If you need to cook or do dishes, she needs to be right by you.
If she wants to go off and play or do something else, you need to remind her that she hasn’t been governing herself, so she’ll have to stay right with you. Remind her of the way she did not obey, and tell her what she needs to do differently next time. Let her know that she’ll be able to go and do those sorts of things when she can be trusted to obey. Every time you have to remind her of why she must stay with you, provide her an opportunity right then to obey you by saying something like “Are you ready to do as I ask?” or “Do you understand what I’m waiting for you to do?” or “Have you thought about what I told you about obeying me?” Then remind her of the task that you wanted her to obey you in.
While she’s spending so much time with you, you can shower her with smiles, talking, listening, physical affection, and telling her how much you love her. Tell her how much better it would be for her to be able to govern herself so that she can be trusted to do something she’d like to go and do.
This can last as long as it takes for her to begin to be trusted to do as you ask. You can tell her to do many things while she is with you, especially to be helpful to you as you go about your own tasks. It may take hours, or even days.
At the same time you need to make sure that your commands and direction for her are delivered in love, for her good, and they’re not beyond her ability to obey. I’ve seen parents expect their children to read their minds and know how to stay out of the parent’s way, while angrily telling them or even yelling at them that they need to obey. Unloving unreasonable demands cause children to feel rejected, confused, and frightened. These things never promote obedience. Make sure that your communications to her are to help her understand what she needs to do, and you’ve given her enough instruction to know how to do it.
You can also begin by talking with her during some morning cuddles about what sorts of behaviors you’ve been noticing and what she needs to do differently. You can encourage her to make it through the day doing the right things. Shower her with kisses and hugs and encouragement to do better. After a few days of this you can let her know what will happen if she continues to behave or disobey as you’ve talked about.
Love empowers obedience, so capture her heart with your love.

















